Showing posts with label Ray Hindes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ray Hindes. Show all posts
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
And suddenly, it's just not so simple anymore
I am referring to the matter of putting Ray Hindes, Jr. back in his seat as councilman of Gloversville's 6th ward.
Until a few hours ago, I was all for it - just to let bygones be bygones, put this chapter in our history behind us, and move along. It really doesn't matter what one thinks of his performance in office - good/bad/indifferent. What matters is that he was elected by his constituents to serve for four years, and it is only reasonable to allow him to do so.
In considering the matter, I did think on the drama surrounding the resignation of former 5th Ward Councilman Mathew Myers, and how that issue might impact this more recent issue.
Contrary to the hysterical ramblings of Jack Kinzie, I believe the events surrounding Myer's resignation, unresignation, and reresignation to be nothing more sinister than a lack of knowledge on everyone's part - made all the more cloudy by green council members, a new mayor, a new city attorney and written rules that said one thing, while a body of common legal precedent apparently went about contradicting the written rules - nothing new there, just look at the exceptions to the Public Officers Law.
And I concluded that it would probably be best, since Matt was a Republican, to let Ray, who is a Democrat, retake his seat.
By doing so, I reasoned, we would be allowing both political parties to have the opportunity to correct mistakes. Call it even, and move along. Then, perhaps, make a city-wide policy (as part of the often lamented but never written Policy and Procedure Manual) that would clarify the matter for future generations.
What I didn't reckon with were the apparent 2nd grade antics that took place at the council meeting in which Mr. Hindes retook his seat on his own and would not leave it.
I certainly believe that action sealed his fate.
Rather than contritely approaching his former council peers and asking for consideration of his request, he bullied his way into the seat without regard to anyone else around him.
I can't imagine he endeared himself to the council by such bully tactics, and it surprises me not at all that he was turned down.
Except.
If it truly is the purview of the person who accepted the resignation to decide whether or not to accept its withdrawal, then perhaps, it could easily be argued, the council's vote in this matter is irrelavent. If Brenda Pedrick is willing to sign off on his return, then it shouldn't matter what happened last night. I don't believe she has the authority/ability to sidestep her responsibility in this matter by moving it up the chain of command.
She didn't move it to the council to decide if Myers should retake his seat, and while that decision was made due to a lot of misunderstanding, for the most part everyone's responsibilities have pretty much been cleared up at this point. She accepted the resignation. She needs to accept, or reject, the rescinding of the resignation.
Except.
Brenda quit.
Now, does the acceptance of the letter accrue to the office, or to the specific person who was in the office at the time it was accepted?
If it is the specific person, and the person is no longer in an official government position, how does this impact things?
To the answer to this question, and many others, I believe we find ourselves heading back to the attorneys, to NYCOM, and the New York State Department of State, Division of Local Government for some answers.
And I predict absolutely no one will be satisfied with whatever will be provided.
I'd strongly recommend the council hold off on filling this vacancy. Putting another person in the chair may end up simply compounding the matter further down the road.
What a headache.
Until a few hours ago, I was all for it - just to let bygones be bygones, put this chapter in our history behind us, and move along. It really doesn't matter what one thinks of his performance in office - good/bad/indifferent. What matters is that he was elected by his constituents to serve for four years, and it is only reasonable to allow him to do so.
In considering the matter, I did think on the drama surrounding the resignation of former 5th Ward Councilman Mathew Myers, and how that issue might impact this more recent issue.
Contrary to the hysterical ramblings of Jack Kinzie, I believe the events surrounding Myer's resignation, unresignation, and reresignation to be nothing more sinister than a lack of knowledge on everyone's part - made all the more cloudy by green council members, a new mayor, a new city attorney and written rules that said one thing, while a body of common legal precedent apparently went about contradicting the written rules - nothing new there, just look at the exceptions to the Public Officers Law.
And I concluded that it would probably be best, since Matt was a Republican, to let Ray, who is a Democrat, retake his seat.
By doing so, I reasoned, we would be allowing both political parties to have the opportunity to correct mistakes. Call it even, and move along. Then, perhaps, make a city-wide policy (as part of the often lamented but never written Policy and Procedure Manual) that would clarify the matter for future generations.
What I didn't reckon with were the apparent 2nd grade antics that took place at the council meeting in which Mr. Hindes retook his seat on his own and would not leave it.
I certainly believe that action sealed his fate.
Rather than contritely approaching his former council peers and asking for consideration of his request, he bullied his way into the seat without regard to anyone else around him.
I can't imagine he endeared himself to the council by such bully tactics, and it surprises me not at all that he was turned down.
Except.
If it truly is the purview of the person who accepted the resignation to decide whether or not to accept its withdrawal, then perhaps, it could easily be argued, the council's vote in this matter is irrelavent. If Brenda Pedrick is willing to sign off on his return, then it shouldn't matter what happened last night. I don't believe she has the authority/ability to sidestep her responsibility in this matter by moving it up the chain of command.
She didn't move it to the council to decide if Myers should retake his seat, and while that decision was made due to a lot of misunderstanding, for the most part everyone's responsibilities have pretty much been cleared up at this point. She accepted the resignation. She needs to accept, or reject, the rescinding of the resignation.
Except.
Brenda quit.
Now, does the acceptance of the letter accrue to the office, or to the specific person who was in the office at the time it was accepted?
If it is the specific person, and the person is no longer in an official government position, how does this impact things?
To the answer to this question, and many others, I believe we find ourselves heading back to the attorneys, to NYCOM, and the New York State Department of State, Division of Local Government for some answers.
And I predict absolutely no one will be satisfied with whatever will be provided.
I'd strongly recommend the council hold off on filling this vacancy. Putting another person in the chair may end up simply compounding the matter further down the road.
What a headache.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Blog Archive
About Me
- Lance M. Gundersen, Sr.
- A lot of authors and bloggers have written about living intentionally. Each define it differently, but the basic gist of the idea is to have a plan and do everything in one's power to make it a reality. My plan was to live debt-free, and then spend my time doing the things I want to do - like finishing at least a Master's in an area I can put to use in my community. I started this process with a Masters in Work and Labor Policy with an Advanced Certificate in City Administration, but then switched to a Master's in Urban Planning focusing on Bike and Pedestrian Infrastructure (and learning a fair bit about environmental planning, Brownfield redevelopment, community planning and more). I have also begun accomplishing a whole basket of cycling, sailing, hiking and personal enrichment goals which are each in various states of accomplishment. Feel free to stop by and read my musings. Comment if you like. Please be respectful, and I apologize that it's even necessary to have to say that at this stage of our existence.
My Political Philosophy
While I identify myself as a Republican, like most people, I do not necessarily identify with every aspect of my party's platform.
I tend toward the Liberty Caucus of the Republican party.
http://www.rlc.org/about/
Yet, at the same time, I have a very Jeffersonian mindset regarding the rightful pre-eminence of the local political structure in everyday American Life.
Basically, I believe in limiting the Federal and State Governments, and allowing local community government, which is much closer to the people, to be the source of most of our political innovation.
Local governments are important for delivering services that might otherwise be unaffordable to individuals. Among these include Police and Fire protection, water and sewer services, trash pick-up and infrastructure maintenance, transit services, and general recreation programs (or providing the land and legal framework within which such programs can function).
I tend toward the Liberty Caucus of the Republican party.
http://www.rlc.org/about/
Yet, at the same time, I have a very Jeffersonian mindset regarding the rightful pre-eminence of the local political structure in everyday American Life.
Basically, I believe in limiting the Federal and State Governments, and allowing local community government, which is much closer to the people, to be the source of most of our political innovation.
Local governments are important for delivering services that might otherwise be unaffordable to individuals. Among these include Police and Fire protection, water and sewer services, trash pick-up and infrastructure maintenance, transit services, and general recreation programs (or providing the land and legal framework within which such programs can function).
Categories
- 2010 Budget (1)
- Al Lebo (1)
- Buybacks (1)
- Castiglione (1)
- City Council (3)
- City Taxes (3)
- DPW (1)
- Email (1)
- Fire Department (2)
- Freedom of Speech (1)
- Garbage Collection (2)
- Garbage User Fee (1)
- Golden Garbage Trucks (1)
- Government (1)
- Hiring Freeze (1)
- Jo-Anne Clear (1)
- Laptop (1)
- Non Profits (1)
- Open Meetings Law (3)
- Police Department (1)
- Politics (5)
- Public opinion (1)
- Raises (1)
- Ray Hindes (1)
- Recovery (1)
- RINO (1)
- Sidewalks (2)
- Stipends (1)
- Tax Solutions (1)
- YMCA (1)